Showing posts with label Journalism and Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Journalism and Media. Show all posts

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Tumeke Blunders

Although a consistent reader of that emphatic critic Martin "Bomber" Bradbury's blog Tumeke, it is with great surprise and sadness that I read Tim Selwyn's ill-thought through response to a post on FrogBlog.

The Green party blog attempted an - I admit somewhat silly - argument on how 1.5billion invested into ultra-fast internet would be wasted money. They argue this on the grounds that: 1. There is no need for such fast speeds. 2. Attention should not be taken away from those consumers who only need the very basics of broadband 3. the economic benefits are uncertain and 4. international bandwidth is the bottleneck.

Selwyn utterly discredited himself with his response:

the Greens are proving once again that they are at their core nothing more than modern day 'Flat Earthers' and that they will use any argument at all (even if it is internally incoherent) in order to align everything to their mantra of stasis
Such knee-jerk reactions are usually loathed on Tumeke. But he gets even worse. In response to the Greens claim
We tend to think that more of a good thing is better and that the things which worked well for us in the past will continue to work well in the future. I see ‘ultra fast broadband’ as a small part of that pattern, along with SUVs, iPads (with $30/mo 3G connection!) transmission gully and Airbus A320s. I see blindness about infinite economic growth on a finite planet (with it’s side effects of climate change and peak oil) as part of that too.

Sometimes, more is just not necessary and simply becomes an extra burden to carry
...Selwyn comments...
This is so moronic it is no wonder the four arguments put up to support the proposition were so flawed. Do they deserve to be in parliament? It is one thing to claim that sometimes more of a good thing isn't better - it's just a burden (we may agree this could apply to chocolate, cocaine, fossil fuel devouring engines and so on); but to claim that this applies to the speed of the internet - the flow of communications and the means of displacing wasteful alternatives (eg. having to commute to work) - is possibly the most idiotic thing I have ever heard from a political party.
I do not presume to defend FrogBlog's argument. And in part I agree with Selwyn: the communication of information is now one of the major crutches of the developed world. Business especially hinges their success on their tele-communication abilities.

What I have trouble with is the "moronic" nature of Selwyn's response. He has jumped straight onto the old bandwagon of painting the Green party as out-of-touch lunatics, putting no thought into what the backdrop to their argument is.

It is always difficult to play the prophet, but the Green party correctly understand the trap that is technology - even technology that seems such a blessing. Whether they are correct in their specific suspicion of the pursuit for greater, and faster internet is questionable. But they can see how the world can no longer sustain itself on the amazing technologies that have offered little except short-term consumer satisfaction and greater Co2 levels in the atmosphere. Their place in parliament is to push the reality than we can no longer think of "more, bigger, faster, better" in terms that are parallel or synonymous with prosperity and happiness. We don't know how much of a trap our evolving tele-communications technology can be, just as the early architects of industrialism couldn't see the dangers that lay in the assembly line, or the factory. But - even if they are wrong - the Green party is still trying to look through the darkness, to offer something constructive.

And for that, Tim Selwyn, they deserve more respect. I expect better from Tumeke.

Monday, October 26, 2009

A Winter Made

One of the problems the environmental movement is facing is the ambivalence of the media. The destruction around us does not suit the dogmatic principles of those in power and is therefore ignored. For the many kiwis who do care about the environment, the consequences are sometimes hard to see. We don't see ecosystems destroyed, water ways polluted, or the overall consequences of the consumer lifestyle when they are not reported.

This is highlighted by Paul Henry's quite incredible ignorance when discussing the environmental impact of plastic bags on Breakfast the other week. He said "what will a plastic bag do, honestly? One plastic bag does not a winter make".

Well on Midway Atoll the albatross are facing extinction, due to parents feeding their chicks plastics - which look like food - they find in the polluted water. On a diet of human trash thousands of Albatross chicks die every year on Midway alone from starvation, toxicity, and choking. Midway is 2000 kilometres away from it's nearest continent.

So for all to see here are the unaltered consequences plastics are having on the bird life on Midway Atoll:






















So thank you once again for your opinion Mr. Henry, but I think the world is better off without it.

Source

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Shameful

Absolutely disgusting journalism from Campbell Live once again.

I have accepted retorts of 'yes, yes we all know it's magazine journalism, let it go'. Well, no I won't let it go. Not when what is supposed to be one of our main vehicles of investigative journalism preludes an interview with an opposition MP with a sugarcoating of the serious conduct by a Deputy Prime Minister by visiting his electorate and asking the people who voted for him and his father their opinion.

What warm fuzzies before we witness the politicking of the single-minded self-interested politician!

This is simply not good enough, and sadly is not a one off occurrence. We will once again visit the journalistic atrocities of Campbell's now institutionalized train wreck of a show in my post on coverage of the Key-New York circus.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Dog = Yum

Here is me throwing my hat in the political ring:

Concerning the story all over the news, here is what I think:
1) There are arguments on both sides, and they both bore me.
2) There has been beige racism since the story hit the media.
3) Diasporic cultures still thrive in New Zealand.

And despite all the hoo-rah-rah around this I can't help but conclude:
A man ate his dog... who gives a fuck? Really.

Because:
1) We should be more understanding of other cultures since,
2) the dog was killed humanely and
3) Despite what you hear on talkback I'm sure the majority of NZers don't have knee-jerk emotional reactions to such stories, despite how icky eating dog might seem.


Can we get back to real issues now?

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Don't Pin It On Us

I'm finding the media commentary surrounding Micahel Jackson's death a little audacious. Reporting from a helicopter Emma Murphy comments:


I'm sorry Emma, but I believe the tidal wave of sorrow and grief after Jackson's death shows that Jackson never truly lost public support. If anything, it was the story-thirsty media that hooked onto Jackson's public stature like a bear-trap during his child molestation allegations and court hearings, and milked it for everything it was worth to win a share of public interest. It was the news and tabloid publications that Jackson fell out of favour with. Not the people.

Is the media, which so brutally tortured Jackson for his entire life with postive and harmfully negative press, now trying to save face in wake of his death, and in the face of such public support for the pop star? It seems so, and their efforts are making them look horribly hypocritical.

The frenzy around the allegations against Michael have become so blurred in history that it is easy to think the people disowned their favourite son. But the trail of blood leads directly to one source, and journalists such as Murphy seem to be looking very flushed. The media should be ashamed for the way it treated Jackson, and I'm sorry, but they're not going to pin this one on the public. It is clear how much people loved him.

I always love it when the media are caught off guard.

EDIT: Note that in that story, even in death Jackson continues to get negative press. His quirky Neverland might be destroying rural communities now!